Horses in Movies & TV
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

3/21/2018

Black Beauty - Cold water and Illness?

6 Comments

Read Now
 
In the movie Black Beauty, there is a scene when after running through a storm all night, Beauty (the horse) is taken care of by the inexperienced stable boy Joe.  Beauty is in his stall, wet and steaming.  Joe refuses to cover Beauty with a blanket thinking he is too hot,  and then proceeds to give him cold water to drink. The next day, Beauty is found lying down and in pain.

Cold Water Myth
This scene may confuse general audiences and horse owners because it implies the cold water - "felt like a kick in the guts" -  is what made Beauty sick. It's still a commonly held belief that if you give a horse ice cold water, especially after a heavy workout, it will colic. However, this is untrue. It's not that the water being cold will make horses sick, it's that horses do not generally like to drink ice cold water.  Drinking cold water is uncomfortable on a horse's stomach making the horse tend not to want to drink much even if it's thirsty. People then draw to the conclusion that cold water makes horses sick when actually the sickness is likely brought on by the lack of enough fluids in the horses' systems.  During very cold winter months, horses are in greater danger of becoming dehydrated because they won't drink as much water if it's nearly frozen, which can lead to colic, hypothermia, and other illness.

Hypothermia and Dehydration
This movie is based off a novel by the same name by Ann Sewell, and she describes more of Beauty's symptoms. Here is an excerpt from the book after the hard ride: I was glad to get home, my legs shook under me, and I could only stand and pant. I had not a dry hair on my body, the water ran down my legs, and I steamed all over....He [Joe] rubbed my legs and my chest, but he did not put my warm cloth on me; he thought I was so hot I would not like it. He then gave me a pail full of water to drink; it was cold and very good, and I drank it all; then he gave me some hay and some corn, and thinking he had done right, he went away.  Soon I began to shake and tremble, and turned deadly cold, my legs ached, my loins ached, by chest ached, and I felt sore all over. 
 
After a horse goes through a strenuous workout, it needs to be walked to help dissipate the excess heat produced by its muscles. Sweating and breathing both release heat from the body to help the horse's core temperature return to normal. If the stored heat is not properly released, it can become trapped in the horse's muscles and its core which can lead to colic and "tying up" aka rhabdomyolysis - a condition of muscle stiffness, pain, and trembling.  At the same time, when a horse is being cooled down, it needs to replace all those lost fluids. Dehydration reduces blood flow to the muscles and organs, which can cause the core temperature to drop and make the horse hypothermic. 

Proper Cool Down and Hydration
Two things that Joe did incorrectly with Beauty is he did not cool him down properly and he did not hydrate him enough.  If your horse has had a hard workout, let it walk until it's breathing normally and not sweating. Also, let it drink. Make sure the water is a comfortable temperature (not ice cold) so the horse will want to drink enough.  Keeping a horse from water while cooling it down may make it more difficult for its body to circulate blood properly and return back to a normal core temperature.  Also, after only the horse is properly cooled and dry can a rug be placed on it. Trapped sweat can make the horse cold later on and also lead to skin problems. 

It seems to be a divisive issue in the equitation community on when to let a horse drink after a hard work out.  If you own a horse, what do you do after  a hard work out? Do you let your horse drink water immediately or do you wait?

Picture
Horses drinking from a stone trough. Painting by Enrico Coleman. [Public Domain]

Share

6 Comments
Mathilde Kvernland link
3/24/2018 10:41:15 am

Wow, this is actually very informative! I always walk him until he stops panting and has a normal heart rate. I try to make sure he gets enough water generally, but my horse doesn't sweat easily, so it's never been a problem! I've had him for 3 years and he has never coliced or shown symptoms!

Reply
Amy Brooks - Horses in Movies & TV
3/25/2018 08:04:01 am

I am glad you liked it! It's good your horse has plenty of water even after working him. That's probably one reason he has not coliced. I had horses growing up, and we never had issues with colic, but they always had access to water and pasture to move around.

Reply
Caroline Towning link
4/2/2018 02:25:24 am

Thank you for writing this- I learnt so much! Great blog

Reply
Emily Stevens
11/27/2018 06:53:05 pm

Hi! I’m really glad I found this site, all this information is fascinating!
I don’t work my horse very hard any more (she’s 25 but still going strong!!!), but my general policy is to let a horse drink as much as they want after a hard workout in the summer, but in the winter when the horse is hot and the water’s cold, I like to hold them off until they’re totally cooled down to keep from shocking their system. Honestly, though, I couldn’t tell you whether or not that’s a GOOD system to use; it’s just what I do.

Reply
Amy - Horses in Movies & TV
11/30/2018 02:46:23 pm

As long as the water is not freezing cold in the winter, your horse should be fine drinking it after working out. I love that you are still working your 25 year old horse. I learned to ride on an old Arabian and he taught me so much.

Reply
Pam Levy link
1/8/2019 06:19:49 am

Great post! I don't ride in winter, but in summer, I tend to let my horse drink as she likes, even if she's hot (having said that, my cool down lasts until she's stopped puffing, so she's typically pretty cool by the time we get back to the barn). :)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    Author

    I am Amy. I love movies, TV, and horses. I grew up with horses and taught kids how to ride during my summer breaks from school. Now I am a country girl living in a city hoping to someday move back into a rural area and own a horse again.

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017

    Categories

    All
    Ben Hur
    Black Beauty
    Charge Of The Light Brigade
    Downton Abbey
    Game Of Thrones
    Hidalgo
    Interview - Les Amis
    Interview - Ronnie B. Goodwin
    Legend
    National Velvet
    Outlander
    The Black Stallion
    Turn: Washington's Spies
    War Horse

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact